The trial of four men accused of murdering Prince Akinloye Ademola and Sheriff Ishola Salami in the Ajiran area of Lagos State opened on Thursday.
Defence lawyers immediately challenged the prosecution’s first witness, questioning his right to present information gathered from other people as evidence of events he did not personally witness.
The objection was raised by senior advocate Olalekan Ojo (SAN), who argued that the police investigating officer must distinguish between facts within his personal knowledge and those obtained from others during the investigation.
The intervention disrupted the prosecution’s opening testimony, setting up an early legal battle over the admissibility and scope of evidence in the high-profile murder trial.
The four defendants are Sefiu Fatai, popularly known as Fabo; Yusuf Ismail, alias Bariga; Tajudeen Ahmed, also known as Ahmed Ajiran; and Bode Ajose.
They are standing trial before Justice Abdul-Raheem Muyideen of the Lagos State High Court sitting at Igbosere.
At Thursday’s proceedings, the Lagos State prosecution team, led by Solicitor-General Adebayo Haroun, called its first witness, Assistant Superintendent of Police (ASP) Nosiru Isiaka, attached to Special Squad 1 of the Lagos State Police Command.
In his evidence-in-chief, Isiaka outlined the steps taken by the police during the investigation, including the arrests of the first and second defendants, Fatai and Ismail.
He also told the court that further investigations, involving a technical team from the office of the Inspector-General of Police, led to the arrest of the third defendant in Ajiran, in Lagos’ Ajah area.
However, as the witness was about to explain how the investigation led to the arrest of the fourth defendant, the defence lawyers raised objections.
Ojo argued that the investigating officer, who was not present when the alleged murders occurred, must not give evidence in a manner suggesting that he personally witnessed the events surrounding the killings.
READ ALSO:
- IGP Disu Urges Hospitals To Treat Gunshot Victims Without Police Reports
- Tinubu To Sign State Police Bill
- Benue Begins Move To End Lingering Gwer, Guma Land Dispute
The senior lawyer maintained that the witness should restrict his testimony to matters within his personal knowledge, particularly the investigative steps he personally undertook.
He further argued that the officer must clearly distinguish between facts established through his own investigation and information allegedly obtained from other people.
According to him, an investigating officer may testify about the investigation but should not present statements or accounts made by others as direct evidence of events he did not witness.
Other defence lawyers also raised objections to aspects of the witness’s testimony, further interrupting the proceedings.
The defence teams included O. Ajanaku and R.O. Owolabi, while Ojo and Gbenga Ojo represented the third defendant. M. Familola appeared for the fourth defendant.
Responding, Haroun urged the court to dismiss the objections, arguing that the court was the appropriate authority to determine whether a statement was properly obtained and voluntarily made by a defendant.
He also contended that the objections raised by counsel to the second and fourth defendants were unwarranted because their clients had not been mentioned in the relevant portion of the witness’s evidence.
The prosecutor consequently urged Justice Muyideen to overrule the objections and allow the testimony to continue.
However, the judge adjourned the matter until 25 November to rule on the objections.
